There is a contradiction at the heart of the AI revolution that threatens to undermine progress.
Organisations are investing heavily in artificial intelligence, encouraging employees to use it and increasingly embedding it into everyday workflows. Yet, at the same time, we are making little headway in ensuring that those same employees truly understand the data that sits underneath it.
That should be a board-level concern.
In the latest Carruthers and Jackson Data Maturity Index, 40% of data leaders reported that AI is now being used by a high number of employees, either across their organisation or within particular departments, up from 21% in 2024. For the first time, no respondents reported that AI was not being used at all. When our next report is published later this year, that number will likely grow further.
But workforce capability is not moving at the same speed.
58% of data leaders told us that most of their employees are not data literate, with a further 3% saying that almost no employees in their organisation are data literate. We’ve been running our survey of data leaders for years now and seen no meaningful year-to-year progress in closing that gap.
The data that lurks beneath…
Organisations are investing significant sums in AI, but if the people using it do not understand the data underneath, we will struggle to realise that investment. The insight we get from data and AI is only as valuable as the decisions people make with them.
Data literacy has traditionally been treated as a specialist capability, something for analysts, data scientists and technology teams, but that is increasingly not the case.
Data literacy is the ability to read, understand, analyse and communicate data in a meaningful way. It means being able to ask the right questions, interpret findings, make informed decisions and communicate data’s value to others, without necessarily having deep technical expertise.
Not everyone needs to know how to build the underlying models, but they do need to know enough to question the output. Is it credible? What assumptions sit behind it? What data is missing? Could there be a bias in the result? Should I act on it?
That is what data literacy boils down to. Without it, we risk creating organisations that are very good at spending on AI, but unable to maximise its potential.
Leadership buy-in
The most-cited barriers in our Data Maturity Index to achieving better data literacy were leadership buy-in, lack of time and resources, deep-rooted cultural resistance and poor access to appropriate training. These obstacles are not primarily technology matters, but they’re deeper organisational issues that start with the leadership group.
For too long, data capability has often been approached through the lens of a technology roadmap: buy the platform, improve the infrastructure, introduce the governance framework, deploy the latest tool, and so on.
These foundational steps have their place, but if the people using those tools do not understand what they are seeing, or do not feel confident challenging it, the value of that investment will be constrained. This is why data literacy needs to move from the margins of the technology agenda into the mainstream of organisational strategy.
And this matters even more now in what I think of as the ‘second coming of data.’
In the not-too-distant past, boards were entering, or perhaps being dragged into, major discussions about organisational approaches to data because of GDPR and the need for compliance. Now, the conversation is different. The questions at the heart of data are much more about purpose.
The second coming of data
Where do we want to go with our data? Why? For whom? And to what end? Organisations are having to think differently about the data they hold, the decisions they make and the outcomes they want to achieve. Data is moving from something organisations only need to manage responsibly, to something they need to deploy deliberately.
That should fundamentally change the conversation at board level. The board does not need to become a room full of data scientists, but it does need to develop a deeper understanding of where value is coming from, what assumptions underpin the insights being presented and where data may be incomplete or misleading. Perhaps most importantly, organisations need to invest in organisational capability as deliberately as they invest in technology.
One of the biggest risks is that data literacy becomes another training programme delegated somewhere in the organisation. If leadership buy-in is one of the principal barriers to improving data literacy, leadership must be part of the solution.
That does not mean giving every employee the same generic training, because a finance director, customer-service employee and software engineer will interact with data and AI in very different ways. Organisations need role-specific literacy embedded into the way people work throughout their onboarding, professional development, decision-making processes and day-to-day workflows.
The same logic needs to apply to data governance. Policies and processes need to be practical and easy to navigate. If governance becomes so complex that employees cannot understand how it applies to their work, it will often be bypassed rather than embedded.
The matter of data literacy extends beyond business, of course. But while governments and education policies need to catch up to the pressing need for a more data literate workforce, the burden for now falls within the organisations who are looking to reap the benefits of their data and the potential it offers.

The second coming of data is not really about data, per se. It is about what organisations can do with it and, ultimately, that comes down to people. Leadership must make that investment deliberately, helping people build the confidence and capability to use data and AI effectively.
By Caroline Carruthers, award-winning data expert and co-founder of global data consultancy Carruthers and Jackson.
- Data & AI
- People & Culture